Do tell Justice Scalia. For which case is it an “abuse of discretion” to “fail to correct a clear error of law on a petition for certiorari”?

October 8th, 2014

During oral arguments in Dart Cherokee Basin Operating Co. v. Owens, Justice Scalia referred to cases he would rather not name, where the Court denies certiorari, as a failure to correct a clear error of law.

JUSTICE SCALIA: Well, I guess it’s an abuse of discretion whenever we fail to correct a clear error of law on a petition for certiorari. Right? And I’m 24 not going to mention any names, but is that the case? It’s an abuse of discretion. I thought we just had the power to say we don’t feel like taking it.

I wonder what cases he could possibly be talking about? Now, there were no laughters indicated on the transcript, but I’ll wait for the audio to check.

H/T Jacob Berlove