Judge To Rule in Ongoing Ashby High-Rise Case

April 22nd, 2014

In the never-ending saga that is the Houston property dispute of Ashby, a judge is poised to rule on whether he will issue a permanent injunction barring construction. The jury determined that the designs for the Ashby high-rise, as submitted were a nuisance. At a hearing yesterday, the judge (in something of a surprise to me) suggested that something less than a permanent injunction may issue. In short, he suggested that if the developer submitted a modified design, that would not be a nuisance (whatever that means in this bizarre case), a partial injunction shall issue. That would, in my mind, disregard the jury’s verdict (which I think was an incorrect verdict). It would seem that a new design would require a new trial with experts and everything. This case should get reversed on appeal in any event due to the incorrect instructions about the nature of what constitutes a nuisance.

Erin Mulvaney has a writeup:

State District Judge Randy Wilson said he was struggling with what would happen next if he rules against developers and permanently blocks the 21-story residential tower. He told attorneys in a Harris County courtroom packed with onlookers that the Ashby case is not as clear-cut as previous nuisance cases, such as a slaughterhouse or tanning facility planned alongside private homes. …

“We know a Maryland Manor is fine, but 21 stories is not fine,” Wilson said after hearing the last of the legal arguments in the case. “But what is? That’s a horse of a different color.”

The judge asked for a final set of documents from attorneys on both sides and promised to make a decision promptly.

“This case has intense public interest and has stretched for some time,” Wilson told the courtroom. “Because of this, I will rule quickly.”

Update: Here is a copy of the City’s letter. Letter to Judge Wilson

slot mpo slot gacor 2025 slot gacor w168mpo mpo slot slot depo 10k slot gacor w168mpo W168MPO slot gacor w168mpo slot online w168mpo