Chief Justice Roberts: “You are not one of the stupid lawyers that we were worried about before.”

November 29th, 2010

Today during oral arguments in Wall v. Kholi, Chief Justice Roberts engaged in this exchange with counsel:

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Why don’t you just call your motion a motion to correct an illegal sentence? Then we wouldn’t have any dispute here, I gather.

MS. MIZNER: Under the State’s theory, there would not be. I did not file this motion.

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: You are not one of the stupid lawyers that we were worried about before.  (Laughter.)

MS. MIZNER: I may be in other respects, Your Honor, but not this one.

That’s reassuring.