Someone on ebay has listed the high school yearbooks for Justices Scalia, Ginsburg, and Breyer! Here is the Scalia listing. (Don’t bother bidding because I already bought it).
Of course, young Nino was in the Thomas More Society.
And he makes a “good point”!
The Ginsburg listing is here. Bidding starts at $150!
A young Ruth Bader was a member of Arista (honor society in New York), Treasurer of the Go-Getters, in the School Orchestra, a Twirler (I would like to see that!), Secretary to English Department Chairman, Feature Editor of the Term Newspaper, and the stupid watermark blocks the last thing. And in case you were wondering, here is 1584 East 9th Street in Brooklyn, RBG’s home. View Larger Map I do not see a plaque there! The Breyer listing is here.
1960’s school annual featuring photographs and text about students and teachers, activities, sports, humor and shots of the school and surrounding, and local advertisement, and including then graduating senior and future Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer who appears in as President of the Scholarship Federation, Debate Award Winner, School Newspaper, Big Brothers, Dance Committee, Ticket Sellers, Carnival, and Math Club.
Here are some of the photos in the listing. Look at that punum! 
It’s hard to make out what it says next to the photo. I think it says :
President of the Scholarship Federation, Debate Award Winner, School Newspaper, Big Brothers, Dance Committee, Ticket Sellers, Carnival, and Math Club.
And look at this pic! Breyer was a champion debater. This must be where he earned the art of the never-ending hypothetical question 
Here is the cover: 
These pics are included, but I can’t quite make out where SGB is. I think he is in the upper, left-hand corner playing tennis, bt I’m not positive. 
I also found Justice Kennedy’s Harvard Law School yearbook. Not quite as cool though. 
Also for a flashback, I previously collected old school photos of several of the other Justices.
Chief Justice Roberts
Justice Scalia
Justice Kennedy
Justice Thomas
Justice Ginsburg
Justice Alito
Justice Sotomayor
Justice Kagan
Justice Souter
H/T Dan Rice