Feb 13, 2013

Posted in Uncategorized

FantasySCOTUS Predictions: Affirmative Action, Corporate Torture, Dog Sniffing, and International Wire-Tapping

Share Button


the-tenThe Supreme Court has only decided nine cases this term, and is on pace to decide at least sixty-five more. In this column, the FantasySCOTUS Prediction Tracker will offer predictions for four of the biggest cases argued so far:

Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin

With almost 400 predictions, Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin is heading towards a reversal of the 5th Circuit, with 61% of members predicting a reversal. This prediction is significant at a 99% confidence level (+/-8.26). Because Justice Kagan has recused, a 4-4 tie will affirm the lower court.

fisher

Affirmative Action, at least as we knew it under the Michigan Affirmative Action cases, is not long for the world.

Justice Prediction SMR Significant
Roberts 82.7% Reverse 1.316 Yes (0.148)
Scalia 91.4% Reverse 1.450 Yes (0.155)
Kennedy 69.5% Reverse 1.104 No (0.135)
Thomas 88.1% Reverse 1.398 Yes (0.152)
Ginsburg 92.2% Affirm 0.179 Yes (0.069)
Breyer 88.1% Affirm 0.262 Yes (0.083)
Alito 86.3% Reverse 1.372 Yes (0.151)
Sotomayor 91.1% Affirm 0.186 Yes (0.070)
Kagan

Recused

All are statistically significant except for Justice Kennedy. The conservative justices are significantly above that predictions would follow the expected default majority, while the liberal justices are significantly below what predictions would follow their expected default minority opposition. In other words, these numbers reflect a statistically significant retrenchment between the ideological camps on the Court.

Prediction: A significant likelihood of reversal.

 

Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum

Kiobel, which was reargued from last year, considers whether Royal Dutch Petroleum, a corporation, can be held liable under the Alien Tort Statute for violation of the laws of nations.

Kiobel

With over 400 votes, it looks like the Supreme Court will scale back corporate personhood for purposes of liability under international law. Over 76% of predictions expect the Supreme Court to affirm the Second Circuit. This prediction is significant at a 99% confidence level (+/-5.47).

Justice Prediction SMR Significant
Roberts 71.3% Affirm 0.946 No (0.11)
Scalia 67.5% Affirm 0.895 No (0.11)
Kennedy 74.9% Affirm 0.986 No (0.11)
Thomas 68.0% Affirm 0.901 No (0.11)
Ginsburg 55.3% Affirm 2.019 Yes (0.27)
Breyer 57.6% Affirm 2.104 Yes (0.27)
Alito 65.5% Affirm 0.868 Yes (0.11)
Sotomayor 54.3% Affirm 1.981 Yes (0.27)
Kagan 53.0% Affirm 1.933 Yes (0.26)

Here, the high significant SMRs for the liberal justices indicate a high likelihood that they will join the conservative justices in an affirming majority. Indeed, there is even the possibility we get a 9-0 opinion to affirm, however on very narrow grounds to reach a consensus position. However, Alito’s SMR that is statistically significantly below 1 indicates that Alito may hold out from agreeing with the other justices in the majority. This will likely not be a divided 5-4 opinion, as some may have anticipated.

Prediction: A near-certain likelihood of affirmance, with a strong likelihood that eight Justices may join the majority, with Justice Alito writing separately.

Florida v. Jardines

Does a drug sniffing dog smelling the front door of a suspected grow house without a warrant violate the Fourth Amendment? The FantasySCOTUS nose knows.

florida

This canine case has over 130 predictions with 61% of members predicting the Supreme Court will affirm the Florida Supreme Court, and find there is no violation of the 4th Amendment. This prediction is significant at a 99% confidence level ((+/-9.09)).

Justice Prediction SMR Significant
Roberts 50.4% Affirm 0.642 Yes (0.15)
Scalia 49.6% Affirm 0.807 No (0.17)
Kennedy 63.6% Affirm 0.853 No (0.17)
Thomas 46.5% Affirm 0.633 Yes (0.15)
Ginsburg 58.1% Affirm 3.687 Yes (0.66)
Breyer 59.7% Affirm 3.531 Yes (0.65)
Alito 48.8% Affirm 0.486 Yes (0.13)
Sotomayor 60.5% Affirm 3.500 Yes (0.65)
Kagan 58.1% Affirm. 3.438 Yes (0.64)

In this case, the low SMRs for Roberts, Thomas, and Alito seem to indicate that they are likely to hold out from joining Scalia and Kennedy in a majority. However, the extremely high SMRs for the liberal justices indicate that they are highly likely to form a majority with Scalia and Kennedy.

Prediction: The Court will affirm the Florida Supreme Court, and find a violation of the Fourth Amendment, but with an unlikely alignment of Justices centered around Justices Scalia and Kennedy.

Clapper v. Amnesty International

Clapper presents a complicated fact pattern in which attorneys for Amnesty International allege that federal agents may have listened to their conversations with clients abroad. Though, this case turns on whether Amnesty has Article III standing to seek prospective relief because they have offered no evidence that any surveillance actually took place.

clapper

The Second Circuit ruled against James Clapper, the Director of National Intelligence. FantasySCOTUS predicts that the Supreme Court will not give the government a round of applause, and rule in favor of Clapper. With over 100 votes, 61% predict an affirmance.

Justice Predictions SMR Significant
Roberts 50.4% Affirm 0.909 No (0.21)
Scalia 49.6% Affirm 1.143 No (0.24)
Kennedy 63.6% Affirm 1.208 No (0.25)
Thomas 46.5% Affirm 0.896 No (0.21)
Ginsburg 58.1% Affirm 2.360 Yes (0.43)
Breyer 59.7% Affirm 2.260 Yes (0.42)
Alito 48.8% Affirm 0.688 Yes (0.19)
Sotomayor 60.5% Affirm 2.240 Yes (0.41)
Kagan 58.1% Affirm 2.200 Yes (0.41)

In this case the high significant SMRs for the liberal justices indicate a high likelihood that they will join the conservative justices in an affirming majority. However, Alito’s SMR that is statistically significantly below 1 indicates that Alito would hold out from agreeing with the other justices in the majority.

Prediction: The Supreme Court will affirm the lower court, and rule in favor of Amnesty International with a broad coalition of Justices, with Justice Alito most likely to write separately, or perhaps Justice Alito is assigned to write a narrow coalition opinion.

Make your predictions today!

Sign up at FantasySCOTUS.net and play like the 10th Justice.

Law Students: Predict on FantasySCOTUS! Research on Westlaw! Play like the 10th Justice. 

There are two ways to win.

Team Competition

With Teams of five students, make predictions on all cases decided after January 25, 2013 (the start date of the competition). Make the best predictions, and win these awesome prizes:

  • (1) Grand Prize: one (1) $300 Visa gift card to each Team Participant
  • (1) First Prize:  one (1) $150 Visa gift card to each Team Participant
  • (1) Second Prize: one (1) $50 Visa gift card to each Team Participant

Individual Competition

Want to play solo? Make predictions on all cases decided after January 25, 2013.

  • The top-ranked player in each eligible law school will receive 1,000 Westlaw Reward points.

Instructions to sign up for individual competition.

 

Please read the official rules for details.

 

-This post was co-authored by Corey Carpenter

 

 

 

Share Button
Print Friendly