Jul 29, 2012

Posted in Uncategorized

Scalia Pulls Rank on Posner



SCALIA: He is a court of the appeals judge, isn’t he?

WALLACE: Yes.

SCALIA: He doesn’t sit in judgment of my opinions as far as I’m concerned.

WALLACE: You sit in judgment of his opinion?

SCALIA: That’s what happens.

I think Judge Posner would disagree with that statement.

Print Friendly
Share
  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=681863557 David Welker

    What I find amusing is Scalia acting like he is not familiar with Richard Posner. Seriously???

    • http://joshblackman.com/ Josh Blackman

      Elsewhere in the interview he suggested that he hadn’t heard any of the criticism about the Court’s opinion in NFIB v. Sebelius. He seems to like playing dumb for dramatic effect.

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

      • Miguel Dickson

        Also, IIRC, a few lines after that, he basically says he was doing it to one-up Posner. So I think the right way to read the question is as a snubbing rhetorical question, or not as a question. (“Oh my, he’s just a lowly CoA judge, isn’t he…”)

  • Pingback: Posner v. Scalia, Round V | Josh Blackman's Blog